I stopped for gas yesterday at my go-to out of the way gas station right that’s near several of my rental properties and as I’m filling up a mini-van full of  a mom, a dad and at least two kids I can see pulls up to fill up as well. Behind the minivan is about a 16 foot trailer and as he gets out to start pumping his gas, a small cute little dog hops out of the van to check out the surroundings.

Now we’ve had a few cooler days recently and it was turning into quite a nice late summer day so as guys tend to do as he’s standing there filling up and as I’m standing there filling up, we start talking about the weather. Which turns into how the next several days are supposed to be great and the upcoming weekend looks like it should be fantastic.

It’s about that point that I bring up the trailer and ask, Are you just getting back, or are you getting ready to head out for the weekend? That’s when things got awkward.

It Wasn’t a Trailer, It Was Home

That’s when he explained to me that they were staying in the trailer because their landlord sold their rental property six months ago and because they had a dog, they couldn’t find another place. He, his wife, his two (or more) kids and the dog had been calling this 16 foot trailer home for half a year. He said “Landlords are being too picky.”

His next comment was how with winter coming up quickly, that they were going to have to start thinking out of the box.

Being a landlord, and starting to feel a little defensive after hearing that, the conversation slowed down at that point, but as we both stood their filling our vehicles, it really made me ponder about pets, rental properties and what the right thing to do was as a landlord.

Now I wasn’t talking about offering up one of my properties, more along the lines of whether it’s right for landlords to not allow pets, or what the repercussions of allowing more pets in our personal rental properties would be.  It became quite an inner monologue with myself for the next half hour as I was driving to meet a landlord, whom I mentor, for coffee.

Seeing a situation where a family is stuck camping because they can’t find housing is a heart breaking situation. You wonder what’s life like for those kids and how tough things must be. School has just started, are they even going, are they allowed to go without any type of permanent address, what if they can’t find a place, what happens to them, and of course should landlords like myself be more lenient about pets?

Life Decisions Can Be Hard

Is there a right course of action when you see this going on? During coffee with Tim I quickly brought up the gas station conversation just to see what Tim’s thoughts were as well. I already knew my answers and had perhaps even rationalized them during my drive, but it never hurts to get other opinions or ideas.

Perhaps as an experiment, maybe you need to stop reading after the next sentence and go write your thoughts about this down in the comment section at the bottom of this article. I realize many of you are just passive readers, but it would be interesting to see your thoughts now and then perhaps any revised ones after the rest of this article.

So if you can, humor me and go leave a comment so far about your thoughts on landlords and pets, then come right back here.

I’ll wait, don’t worry…

Still waiting…

Done yet?

My Thoughts On Pets and Rentals

My discussion with Tim didn’t actually change my thoughts, rather it just cemented them. It’s my property and it’s my decision and if it comes down to two equally qualified tenants, one with a pet, one without a pet, 100 out of 100 times, the tenants without the pets get the property.

It’s so 100 out of 100 that almost always my advertisements say no pets and when prospective tenants call, yes small dogs, kittens and chinchillas are all pets, but thank you for calling.

It’s not that I’m against pets. I personally have two cats and a gerbil in my household and even had a cat back 25 plus years ago when I was a tenant. And I do have one older tenant in a house with two small dogs, so I’m not entirely ice-hearted.

The problem ends up being, the risk of tenants having pets isn’t worth the reward and that is the one phrase you have to remind yourself about.

And while it might be unfair, in someone’s mind, to the responsible pet owners out there it’s not them taking the risk and the chance that that Missy may pee on the carpet, unaware to them or you. Or more often, well aware to the tenant, that Spot has destroyed the back yard and he’s left hundreds of little surprises under the blanket of snow for you to deal with in the spring now that they have moved on.

Experience has taught me that having to replace that carpet, even though it wasn’t a large carpeted area, cost me money. Not just the cost of replacing the carpet, but the extra two weeks I was vacant as I waited to get the carpet replaced. It adds up, and it didn’t have to.

Experience has taught us that cleaning up after someone else’s dog is complete crap. (Although a quick tip we learned the hard way is it’s best to do it first thing in the morning in the spring as it’s way less fun to pick up once it warms up).

I feel bad for tenants who can’t find rental places because they have pets, but I never forced them to get a pet. They made the decision and reduced ability to find good rental properties is part of the price. I understand the pet being part of the family and I understand how having pets can help kids be more well rounded (sometimes debatable).

What I can’t understand is the decision to have multiple large dogs, to know you will be a renter for an extended period if not forever and then to announce that it’s unfair that landlords don’t accept pets. Or the crazy cat lady/family who can’t find new housing. Those folks I don’t really feel bad for.

You’ve made poor or outright bad decisions that you have to live with and now it is indeed time for you to make harder decisions. Perhaps it’s time to give up that pet until you are in a position to own your own home and make your own rules.

Anyways, that’s my thoughts and I’d love to hear yours! So leave me a comment below.