How A Car In The Garage Won Us A Rental Property In A Bidding War

Negotiating A Rental Purchase

We’ve bought a lot of rental properties over the years and while we ended up with many that we wanted (some perhaps we shouldn’t have wanted so bad), we’ve also missed out on many along the way.

Sometimes at a rental property we saw things that would affect the value or would require too much time and energy to repair and we avoided purchasing them and sometimes we saw certain features that made the property attain “must have” status in our minds. Of course the important part is the property had to work.

And by work, I mean it had to fit the particular mold for what we were purchasing the rental property for. During our heyday, we bought properties we renovated and flipped, we bought properties we turned into regular rental properties and we had properties we turned into high cash flow rooming houses.

Depending on the features, the area and of course the price, we knew we could usually fit a property into one of these systems.

If it was outdated and in need of renovations, we knew it might make a great flip property, if it was in the right neighborhood and had the right floor plan, perhaps it could be our next rooming house or if it was already suited, maybe this was our next rental property!

To help streamline this process, having a good Realtor can be a huge help. On the other hand, having a Realtor who doesn’t understand you can also be a huge pain in the a$$. In this tale of how a car helped us win a bidding war, the Realtor was a pain and it wasn’t long after this we parted ways.

It Pays To Pay Attention

At the time we were looking for a new rental property to add to our portfolio. We’d recently flipped a property and we wanted to move those profits into a property that would generate a nice return, so our Realtor at the time found us a nice property in a great rental neighborhood that had just come on the market.

It had just come on the market so we knew we needed to see it ASAP, as we felt it wouldn’t last long, so we had the Realtor setup an appointment right away and went to view it that evening.

It needed some work, but it was perfect for our needs. Three bedrooms up, partially finished basement with the laundry near the bottom of the stairs and a detached garage. We knew we could quickly suite the basement area and turn it into a nice little one bedroom unit, the garage had a furnace in it, so it could be rented as a heated garage and the upstairs was dated, but had great bones.

But perhaps the most important part was, the owner stayed at the property while we toured it and helped us out by telling us all the important details about the property. This is a rare occurrence as typically the Realtor who lists the house advises the owner to make themselves scarce during the showings.

You simply never know what might sneak out of the owner’s mouth that may hinder a sale or perhaps give potential buyer’s an advantage when it comes to negotiating. It’s access to unfiltered information about the house!

True to form, this homeowner followed us through on the tour and gave us plenty of extra tidbits, mostly about how much he was going to miss the home as he was moving to be closer to family, but also a couple little tidbits that were going to be beneficial to both parties. And this is why it pays to pay attention.

Ramblin’ On

It was when we looked at the detached garage we hit the jackpot.

Although it was full of tools, treasure and junk, there was also something buried under a tarp in one of the parking spaces. Since it never hurts to ask, we asked what it was.

Buried underneath it was a 1963 Rambler that the owner had one day hoped to restore. During the next 20 minutes he told us all the details about how he loved the car, had hoped to fix it up and then one day give it to his daughter, but instead it had just ended up sitting there being neglected.

You could hear his disappointment as he told us how he was now going to likely have to just give it away to some parts place or to try and sell it somewhere and would never realize his dream. As we finished the tour, we knew it was a property that worked for us and my wife already had a strategy in her mind to help ensure we got it as we knew there was at least one other interested party who was potentially putting in an offer that night already.

Unfortunately in this world, there are many folks who would use the extra information we had to take advantage of someone and outright deceive them. Deceiving people has never been our goal, we always wanted to make deals that worked for both sides, deals that were win win and where everyone was a winner and comes out happy.

So my wife came up with the perfect offer to achieve that.

We put in a full price offer, but it had one big condition in it.

The sale had to include the car. This condition just about put our Realtor over the roof, he thought we were nuts (and this was another reasons we were soon done with him).

We knew the car was a big concern for this fellow and we felt that just knowing that someone was interested in taking the car would help put his mind at ease.

Again, this wasn’t some slimy negotiating tactic, we saw how much he loved that car and wanted to get it back on the road, so that became part of our goal for it as well. We weren’t just going to acquire the home and the car and then scrap the car, we wanted to make sure it got taken care of too.

As it turns out, there was another offer that went in that night too. An offer that was actually higher than ours. But it didn’t include the car or any mention of it.

And The Winner Is?

Now I can’t remember whether it was later that night or first thing the next morning when we got the news, but even though the other bid was higher than ours, the homeowner went with ours. So who was the real winner?

Both parties! The homeowner got the price he was asking and someone to take his car. Was the car the only reason he went with us?

Part of it may be that he spent time with us on the tour and liked us, part of it might  be that we explained what we would do with the property and how we would take care of it, but mostly we do believe it was about the car. He knew someone was going to take care of it and help take one more problem off his hands.

And The Lesson Is?

None of this would be really helpful to you if there isn’t a lesson to learn from it as you go along and hopefully you already see it. It’s two parts actually.

First, it’s basically that paying attention to some of the details (and getting lucky by having the homeowner hang around) can help you with your negotiating.

Second, armed with extra information you can turn your negotiation into a win win scenario where everyone gets what they want.

As for the car?

Unfortunately, we had to sell it. My wife had visions of us restoring it and possibly giving it to one of our oldest daughter  at some point (really I think she just wanted to cruise around in a cool looking car). We didn’t just sell it to a scrap yard though, we found someone else who intended to restore it.

So how it ended up, we’re not quite sure as we never followed up with the fellow we sold the vehicle too, but we can only hope it was returned to it’s former glory.

Now, since this isn’t one of my typical landlord tips or advice articles, my question for you, would you like more posts along this vein? Posts or articles that talk about deals or strategies we used to buy properties? Let me know and tell me your thoughts on this story, I love to hear your thoughts!